TaylorMade Tour Response vs. Titleist Pro V1 golf balls

Published:

The TaylorMade Tour Response golf ball promises premium tour-level performance at a compression and price to suit an amateur golfer's swing speed and budget... but how does it perform against the market-leading Titleist Pro V1?

After surveying thousands of average golfers and listening to what they wanted from a golf ball, TaylorMade came up with the three-piece Tour Response. They were targeting amateurs who were playing balls that weren't suited to them, hoping to provide a product that not only performed better, but at a cheaper price point.

Related: TaylorMade Tour Response – full review

The intention was to lure people away from premium tour balls like the market-leading Titleist Pro V1, so we thought it made sense to compare the two head-to-head to see how they stack up and which one is better for your golf game. 

TaylorMade Tour Response vs. Titleist Pro V1 – Construction and cover material

Both the TaylorMade Tour Response and Titleist Pro V1 are three-piece golf balls with a 100% urethane cover. It's urethane that makes a ball feel soft and helps with grab and control when it hits the green.

Related: TaylorMade Spider FCG putter revealed

Urethane has typically only been used on premium tour balls, with cheaper balls having surlyn and ionomer covers which don't sound and feel as soft, or provide as much short game control and spin. Thankfully, that is changing, with Tour Response is a ball aimed squarely at amateurs but still offering the urethane cover that discerning golfers will want. 

Balls like the Callaway ERC Soft and Titleist Tour Soft feature blended covers, which can't match what you get from 100% urethane. 

TaylorMade Tour Response golf ball

TaylorMade Tour Response vs. Titleist Pro V1 – Compression

The Titleist Pro V1 has a compression of over 100 (our robot golf ball test measured it at 101.8), while the Titleist Pro V1x has a compression of 108.4, making it the firmest golf ball in our entire test. That's because they're designed for tour players with swing speeds typically in the range of 110-130mph. 

Related: Which TaylorMade iron is right for you?

The TaylorMade Tour Response has a compression of 70, which makes it far easier to compress for golfers with more average swing speeds, helping amateur golfers get more ball speed and distance. 

TaylorMade Tour Response vs. Titleist Pro V1 – Price

The Titleist Pro V1 has an RRP of £52 per dozen, which works out at £4.33 per ball. 

The TaylorMade Tour Response has an RRP of £39.99 per dozen, which works out at £3.33 per ball, 23% cheaper than the Titleist Pro V1. 

Related: 2020 wedges – ranked by spin rate

TaylorMade Tour Response golf ball

Related: TaylorMade Tour Response golf ball tested by you

TaylorMade Tour Response vs. Titleist Pro V1 – Feel

Thanks to the urethane covers, both balls feel pleasantly soft and sticky in the hand, in contrast to surlyn balls which feel hard and less grippy. 

TaylorMade Tour Response vs. Titleist Pro V1 – Performance

In our test, the Titleist Pro V1 was one yard longer off the tee (a difference of 0.4%) than the TaylorMade Tour Response. 

With a 7-iron, the TaylorMade Tour Response was 13 yards (8.8%) longer than the Titleist Pro V1, which means you more than gain back any loss from the driver.

There's always the worry that golf balls carrying further with irons will mean lower spin and shots that don't stop on the green. In fact the TaylorMade Tour Response launched higher, had a higher peak height and the same descent angle as the Titleist Pro V1, meaning shots will hold the green. The extra distance came from a ball speed that was 3mph faster than the Pro V1. 

The Titleist Pro V1 generated 11% more wedge backspin, but again the Tour Response launched higher, peaked at the same height and fell onto the green at a slightly steeper angle, which meant shots still checked up.

TaylorMade Tour Response vs Titleist Pro V1 – Test data

TaylorMade Tour Response golf ball

TaylorMade Tour Response vs. Titleist Pro V1 – Key stats

TaylorMade Tour Response golf ball

Related: Best Drivers 2020

TaylorMade Tour Response vs. Titleist Pro V1 – Final verdict

Overall, for club golfers, the TaylorMade Tour Response golf ball is an excellent alternative to the Titleist Pro V1. Unless you boast a tour pro swing speed, it will likely offer improved performance at a cheaper price point. 

Related: How Rory McIlroy chose his 2020 TaylorMade golf clubs

Simon Daddow

Review by: Simon Daddow   

Job title: Today's Golfer - Equipment Editor

Twitter  Facebook   Instagram  YouTube