Is Tiger Woods’ 2008 US Open win his greatest Major victory?

Published:

Ahead of the 2021 US Open at Torrey Pines, we rank and rate Tiger Woods’ Major wins to find out if his 2008 victory was the greatest of his career.

Today's Golfer's 2021 Major coverage is brought to you in association with TaylorMade.

The last time the US Open was played at Torrey Pines in 2008, Tiger Woods was victorious, beating Rocco Mediate on a sudden death hole after an 18-hole Monday play-off, all while playing with a broken leg.

US OPEN 2021: Who will win at Torrey Pines?

As the US Open returns to the South Course in San Diego for the first time since Woods’ famous win, the 15-time Major champion will be missing from the field as he continues to recover from the injuries sustained in a car crash in February.

Tiger Woods celebrates winning the 2019 Masters at Augusta National Golf Club.

But it got us thinking, where does 2008’s victory rank among Tiger’s Grand Slam successes? Was his incredible and unexpected victory at the 2019 Masters better? What about Tigers sensational first Major win as a 21-year-old at the 1997 Masters?

While Jack Nicklaus’ 18 Major victories remains the yardstick by which all golfers will be compared, Tiger’s performances have seen him break numerous scoring records, performed feats not far short of miraculous and change the face of golf forever.

US OPEN 2021: Win TaylorMade's staff golf bag!

In fact, a strong argument can be made that, at his considerable best, the now 45-year-old Californian played golf at a higher level than any other player in history.

For many years, Tiger Woods name appearing on a Major leaderboard was enough to strike fear into his fellow competitors.

But which one of Tiger Woods’ Major wins was the best? To create our definitive list, we took five key factors into account and gave them a ranking out of 10. First, we looked at Tiger’s dominance and his winning margin over the field.

Then we looked at the quality of his play and the excitement and drama generated. We also took into account the historical relevance of Woods’ victory and whether he broke any important performance or scoring records. We combined all five factors to come up with an overall ranking out of 50.

US OPEN 2021: Torrey Pines Course Guide

Tiger Woods celebrating Major wins has become a familiar picture over the years.

Tiger Woods’ Major wins ranked and rated

KEY

WM: Winning Margin. LoP: Level of Play. D: Drama. HS: Historical Significance. RB: Record Breaking

Tiger Woods puts on the Green Jacket after winning the 2002 Masters.

15. 2002 Masters

This was, at the time, your patented Tiger Woods Major Championship victory. After lurking just off the lead for two days, Woods suddenly found himself tied for the lead with Retief Goosen and a handful of strokes ahead of arch rivals Vijay Singh, Sergio Garcia and Phil Mickelson with a round to play.

As often happened in those days, however, the rest of the field completely disintegrated in his presence and Woods played steady percentage golf to enjoy a comfortable yet entirely predictable three-stroke victory. Ho-hum.

WM: 5 | LoP: 6 | D: 4 | HS: 1 | RB: 1 | Total: 17/50

Tiger Woods won the 2006 US PGA Championship at Medinah.

14. 2006 US PGA Championship

Another win, another record – this time becoming the first man ever to win the US PGA twice at the same venue (Medinah). He was pushed hard for the victory though – at least for a while.

Tied with Englishman Luke Donald, searching for his first major championship victory, with 18 holes to play, Woods cruised to a final round 68 while his playing partner crumbled with a 74. Woods eventually won by five shots from 2003 champion Shaun Micheel.

Yet again, the famous Woods mystique was more than enough to get it done in majors against a typically cowering opposition. 

WM: 7 | LoP: 6 | D: 5 | HS: 2 | RB: 3 | Total: 23/50 

US OPEN 2021: Tee times and groupings at Torrey Pines

Tiger Woods ended his Major winless streak at the 2005 Masters.

13. 2005 Masters

Unusually, Woods arrived in Augusta for his 11th Masters winless in his 10 previous major championships. It was – not for the last time – a streak that was becoming a bit of an issue. And this was hard work, especially after an opening 74 left him seven shots behind leader Chris DiMarco.

Still six back at halfway,Woods made what was to prove (eventually) the killer thrust on day three, a 65 that bequeathed a three-shot edge going into the final round. It was one he needed though. Bogeys on 17 and 18 dropped him into a play-off with DiMarco, one he would win with a birdie at the first extra hole.

WM: 6 | LoP: 7 | D: 8 | HS: 4 | RB: 3 | Total: 28/50 

Tiger Woods won the 2007 US PGA Championship at a stifling hot Southern Hills.

12. 2007 US PGA Championship

It was one of the few things Tiger Woods had never done in any Major Championship: shoot 63. But he ticked that off his “to-do” list on day two at a stifling Southern Hills in Tulsa.

In fact, he could hardly have come closer to becoming the first man to shoot 62 in any of the four Grand Slam events. Just when it seemed to be heading for the bottom of the cup, his putt on the last green somehow lipped-out.

No matter. In the end, Woods was a comfortable winner. Ahead by two shots at the halfway mark, he did what he always seemed to do in such situations – fairways and greens – and was never caught.

WM: 6 | LoP: 9 | D: 5 | HS: 5 | RB: 4 | Total: 29/50 

Tiger Woods' second US Open win came at Bethpage.

11. 2002 US Open

The middle of Woods’ three “national Opens,” as his compatriots refer to it, was his second major title of the year and set in motion talk of another – this time even more historic – “Tiger Slam.”

That wasn’t to be, courtesy of the Scottish weather at Muirfield and Ernie Els a month later, but the three-under-par aggregate Woods shot at Bethpage was impressive enough.

Over what he called the “narrowest US Open course I’ve ever played,” he was the only man in red figures after 72 holes, three shots clear of perennial runner-up Phil Mickelson.

WM: 6 | LoP: 8 | D: 7 | HS: 5 | RB: 5 | Total: 31/50 

US OPEN 2021: Our winner revealed

Tiger Woods won the 2005 Open Championship at St Andrews.

10. 2005 Open Championship

Back at St Andrews, Woods yet again underlined his dominance on golf’s ultimate strategic venue with a five-stroke victory over Colin Montgomerie.

Perhaps just as significantly, it marked Jack Nicklaus’ last appearance in the game’s oldest event. On the course where he had twice won previously, the Golden Bear went out on a typically high note with a 15-foot birdie on the final green.

That day was Jack's, but yet again the week belonged to Woods. “If ever a course was built for him, this is it,” sighed Monty.

WM: 8 | LoP: 8 | D: 7 | HS: 6 | RB: 5 | Total: 34/50 

Victory at the 2001 Masters saw Tiger Woods briefly hold all four men's Major titles.

8=. 2001 Masters

By itself, this was just another major victory for Woods. But his second win at Augusta National – this time by two shots from David Duval – had a much wider significance.

For two months at least, Woods would hold all four Grand Slam titles, a feat comparable only with Bobby Jones’ annexing of the previous version back in 1930. The only caveat this time, of course, was that the so-called “Tiger Slam” was not accomplished in a calendar year.

No matter. No one had ever achieved the feat before and no one has managed to do it again since.

WM: 4 | LoP: 7 | D: 5 | HS: 10 | RB: 10 | Total: 36/50 

RELATED: What the Masters champion wins

Tiger Woods held off Sergio Garcia to win the 1999 US PGA Championship.

8=. 1999 US PGA Championship

Perhaps most memorable for the shot Sergio Garcia played from the foot of a tree with his eyes shut – closely followed by a run, skip and jump up Medinah’s 16th fairway – this was Woods’ second major victory. And one of the narrowest.

Knowing he needed two pars to win, the then 23-year old made a clutch eight-footer on the penultimate hole, then two-putted from distance on the final green to edge out the even-younger Spaniard by a single shot.

It was billed as the beginning of a long and hard-fought rivalry, but in the years since, Woods has added 12 more majors to Garcia's one.

WM: 6 | LoP: 8 | D: 9 | HS: 8 | RB: 5 | Total: 36/50 

Tiger Woods was made to work hard for his Major victory at the 2000 US PGA Championship.

7. 2000 US PGA Championship

While Woods routinely saw off big-name challengers, he sometimes had trouble beating less-likely individuals. This was one such case.

In an epic duel that spilled over into a three-hole play-off, Bob May shot 66 around Valhalla three days in a row and still found himself beaten. Typically too, Woods made vital putts, most notably a sliding five-footer on the 72nd to join the play-off.

“This was my most exciting major from a player’s standpoint,” said Woods. “Usually you can just kind of cruise in with pars and win. That wasn’t going to be the case today.” No indeed. 

WM: 6 | LoP: 8 | D: 10 | HS: 7 | RB: 7 | Total: 38/50

Tiger Woods win at the 2006 Open Championship was an emotional one, coming just a few weeks after his father's death.

3=. 2006 Open Championship

This was a clinic. On a burned yellow Hoylake course, Woods used his driver once in 72 holes en route to a two-shot victory over fellow American, Chris DiMarco.

The now three-time Open champion teed his long iron after long iron from tee and fairway. For links golf devotees, it was a throwback to when the game at the highest level was played more on the ground than in the air.

This was too, Woods’ most openly emotional victory. Only a few weeks after the death of his father, Earl, he burst into tears and fell into caddie Steve Williams’ arms after holing the winning putt.

WM: 7 | LoP: 10 | D: 7 | HS: 9 | RB: 8 | Total: 41/50 

Tiger Woods won the 2000 Open Championship by eight shots at St Andrews.

3=. 2000 Open Championship

Only three weeks after his 15-shot US Open victory at Pebble Beach, Woods underlined his superiority with an eight-shot win at St Andrews. In doing so, he completed the career Grand Slam – the youngest and only fifth man to do so – and, remarkably, he did not find one of the fearsome bunkers. His 269 aggregate was the lowest-ever Open score at golf’s most famous venue.

There was time too, for a touch of symbolism. As Woods waited to begin his second round, Jack Nicklaus (who missed the cut by six shots) was putting out on the adjacent 18th green.

WM: 10 | LoP: 10 | D: 1 | HS: 10 | RB: 10 | Total: 41/50 

Tiger Woods' first Major victory came in spectacular style at the 1997 Masters.

3=. 1997 Masters

In the beginning, there was an inexperienced young pro who, playing with defending champion Nick Faldo, was four-over through nine. By the end, golf had, at 21, the youngest-ever Masters winner and a new black superstar.

In cruising to a 12-shot win, Tiger Woods reduced Augusta National to little more than pitch-and-putt, routinely hitting short iron second shots into even the par 5s. Records tumbled. Woods’ aggregate of 270 was a Masters low.

His nine-stroke 54-hole lead was the biggest ever. And he played the last three rounds in a record 16-under par (66-65-69).

WM: 10 | LoP: 10 | D: 1 | HS: 10 | RB: 10 | Total: 41/50 

RELATED: Eyewitness - The inside story of Tiger's 1997 Masters win

Tiger Woods 15th Major victory was perhaps the most unexpected, coming at the Masters in 2019.

3=. 2019 Masters

The most recent and, perhaps, most unexpected victory.

At first glance, the numbers are not startling. On a day when the weather was far from extreme – blustery at most – Tiger Woods began the final round of the 2019 Masters two shots off the lead, shot a two-under par 70 and donned his fifth Green Jacket.

He was 13-under par for the week. Not awful, clearly. But also far from spectacular. In fact, it is the third-highest of Tiger’s five winning scores. Ah, but there is more to golf – especially competitive golf at the elite level – than mere statistics. And for those who knew what they were looking at, Tiger’s play over the closing 18 holes was something of a masterclass.

As other, high-profile contenders around him faltered, the now 15-time major champion went serenely about his business, hitting the shots required – and no more – all the way from first to last. Not once did he get impatient. Not once did he hit the wrong shot at the wrong time.

For those reasons alone, this was one of Tiger’s better Grand Slam wins, one that merits a high-ranking on his almost peerless list. A strong tie for third seems about right.

WM: 8 | LoP: 8 | D: 9 | HS: 10 | RB: 6 | Total:  41/50 

Tiger Woods won the 2000 US Open by 15 shots at Pebble Beach.

2. 2000 US Open

This was as close as professional golf has come to seeing total domination. The only man under par for 72 holes – and the first-ever to record a double-digit under-par winning score – Tiger claimed the 100th US Open title by 15 shots.

Other records tumbled too. This was the largest winning margin in a major. And Woods became the first golfer ever to win the US Junior, Amateur and Open Championships.

The tributes were many and fulsome, but future US Open winner, Michael Campbell, perhaps put it best: “The man is a freak of nature, worlds apart from us in every way.”

WM: 10 | LoP: 10 | D: 2 | HS: 10 | RB: 10 | Total:  42/50 

US Open 2021: What does the champion win?

Tiger Woods 2008 US Open victory took 91 holes and saw him play on a broken leg.

1. 2008 US Open

No one has ever won a major playing on one leg. But the then 32-year-old Tiger Woods came close at Torrey Pines when he claimed his third US Open – and last event of 2008. Even a torn anterior cruciate ligament in his left knee and stress fractures in his left tibia weren’t enough to prevent the greatest golfer of his generation from annexing his 14th (and, to date, last) major title.

Truly, it was epic stuff on what was supposed to be the final round, the highlight surely the bumpy 10-foot putt Woods holed on the 72nd green to force an 18-hole play-off with Rocco Mediate. But even that wasn’t enough to decide the winner. Tied on 71, the pair went one more extra hole before Woods prevailed with an anti-climactic par.

“This is probably the greatest tournament I ever had,” said the champion. “But I’m glad I’m done. I really don’t feel like playing any more.” And he didn’t. Not in 2008 anyway. Two days later, Woods underwent reconstructive surgery on his left knee. Even with 2019’s incredible Masters triumph, some might say he hasn’t quite been the same man – or golfer – since.

WM: 8 | LoP: 10 | D: 10 | HS: 10 | RB: 8 | Total: 46/50

Tiger Woods and Rocco Mediate shake hands after their incredible play-off at the 2008 US Open.

Rocco Mediate: What it was like going head-to-head with Tiger

”People often ask me if I expected Tiger to hole that 25-foot putt on the 18th green at Torrey Pines to force a play-off. The thing is I didn’t expect him to hole it, I knew he would. It’s what he does.

"It’s always fun playing with Tiger because the excitement level goes through the roof. I don’t know about other players but every time I play with him, I feel he gets me focused and makes me play better.

"Everyone expected me to get murdered in that play-off, but I knew that was never going to happen. Even when I was three shots down early on, I thought that if I could get myself together

"I would be just fine and I was a shot in front five holes later. That changed the whole atmosphere.

"It was the loudest, most amazing four hours on a golf course in my life. You almost had to cover your ears walking between holes because there were 30,000 people following us – and that was on a Monday!”

READ NEXT: Tiger Woods' racism and bigotry battle